Pope sacks cardinal in charge of sex abuse cases, a conservative critic

We’re sorry, this feature is currently unavailable. We’re working to restore it. Please try again later.

Advertisement

This was published 6 years ago

Pope sacks cardinal in charge of sex abuse cases, a conservative critic

By Nicole Winfield
Updated

EDITOR'S NOTE: The High Court overturned Cardinal George Pell's conviction for historic child sex offences in a judgment handed down April 7, 2020. In a unanimous decision all seven High Court judges found Victoria's Court of Appeal should not have upheld Pell's conviction It found the evidence could not support a guilty verdict.

Rome: Pope Francis has sacked the head of the Vatican office that handles sex abuse cases, just days after he released Australian cardinal George Pell to return home to face charges of historical sexual assault.

The developments underscored how the Catholic Church's sex abuse crisis has caught up with Francis, threatening to tarnish his legacy.

Francis on Saturday declined to renew the mandate of German cardinal Gerhard Mueller as prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, the Vatican office that processes and evaluates all cases of priests accused of raping or molesting minors.

Cardinal Sean O'Malley, the archbishop of Boston, right, and Marie Collins at a press conference at the Vatican.

Cardinal Sean O'Malley, the archbishop of Boston, right, and Marie Collins at a press conference at the Vatican.Credit: AP

Most incumbents keep the post until they retire, which in Mueller's case would have been in six years. Francis named Mueller's deputy, Monsignor Luis Ladaria Ferrer, a 73-year-old Spanish Jesuit, to run the powerful office instead.

Ladaria is said by those who know him to be a soft-spoken person who shuns the limelight. Mueller, by contrast, often appears in the media.

"They speak the same language and Ladaria is someone who is meek. He does not agitate the Pope and does not threaten him," said a priest who works in the Vatican and knows both Mueller and Ladaria, asking not to be named.

During Mueller's five-year term, the congregation amassed a 2000-case backlog and came under blistering criticism from Irish abuse survivor Marie Collins, who had been tapped by Francis in 2014 to advise the church on caring for abuse victims and protecting children from paedophile priests.

Advertisement
Ousted: Cardinal Gerhard Mueller, the head of the Vatican office that handles sex abuse cases.

Ousted: Cardinal Gerhard Mueller, the head of the Vatican office that handles sex abuse cases.Credit: AP

Collins resigned from the papal commission in March, citing the "unacceptable" level of resistance from Mueller's office to heeding the commission's proposals.

In May, Francis said her criticism of the slow pace in processing abuse cases was justified and announced he was adding more staff to handle the overload.

New man: Monsignor Luis Ladaria Ferrer is, like the Pope, a member of the Jesuit order.

New man: Monsignor Luis Ladaria Ferrer is, like the Pope, a member of the Jesuit order.Credit: AP

Earlier this year he also named Cardinal Sean O'Malley as a member of the congregation in hopes of ensuring better cooperation.

Mueller is one of several cardinals in the Vatican who have publicly sparred with the Pope.

Accused: Cardinal George Pell arrives to meet the media at the Vatican on Thursday.

Accused: Cardinal George Pell arrives to meet the media at the Vatican on Thursday.Credit: AP

In 2015 both he and Cardinal Pell were among 13 cardinals who signed a secret letter to the Pope complaining that a meeting of bishops discussing family issues was stacked in favour of liberals. The letter was leaked, embarrassing the signatories.

"Clearly, the Pope and Cardinal Mueller have not been on the same page for five years," the priest said.

Cardinal Pell with pope Benedict XVI in Sydney in 2008.

Cardinal Pell with pope Benedict XVI in Sydney in 2008.Credit: AP

Mueller has criticised parts of a 2016 papal treatise called "Amoris Laetitia" (The Joy of Love), a cornerstone document of Francis' attempt to make the 1.2 billion-member Church more inclusive and less condemning.

In it, Francis called for a Church that is less strict and more compassionate towards any "imperfect" members, such as those who divorced and remarried, saying "no one can be condemned forever".

At odds: Pope Francis with Cardinal Gerhard Ludwig Mueller at the Vatican in 2014.

At odds: Pope Francis with Cardinal Gerhard Ludwig Mueller at the Vatican in 2014.Credit: AP

"This gives the Pope the chance to finally place his own man in a very important spot," said the Reverend James Martin, an editor-at-large for the Catholic magazine America and a consultant to the Vatican's Secretariat for Communication. "For many admirers of [Pope] Benedict [XVI], Cardinal Mueller was the last link to Benedict's way of doing things."

Taken together, the departure of two arch-conservatives is a serious setback to critics of Francis. They do not see the Pope as an avuncular pastor but instead fear that he is a deft political operator in the midst of a house-cleaning of conservatives.

During the Pope's trip to Philadelphia in September 2015, Mueller said "it's not possible" for violators of church doctrine on divorce, homosexuality or abortion to be welcomed completely back into the church. "It's not an academic doctrine, it's the word of God," he said.

Asked in the interview whether the Pope was as tough a boss as many critics in the Vatican suggested, Mueller grinned and said: "It's a secret."

Loading

When it was noted that his staying in his job seemed like a promising sign, Mueller laughed.

AP, Reuters, New York Times

Most Viewed in World

Loading